State Farm 18.87% 4.4 2. Progressive 16.73% 4.7 3. Geico 11.63% 4.5 4. Allstate 10.19% 4.5 5. USAA** 6.7% 4.8 6. Farmers Insurance 3.76% 4.4 7. Liberty Mutual 3.27% 4.4 8. Travelers 2% 4.9 9.

State Farm is the biggest auto insurance company in the country by market share. Progressive, Geico and Allstate are the next three largest. Most of the largest companies in the country are familiar ...

the savings they bring usually will not make Allstate cheaper than competitors like Geico and Progressive. Customers report that Allstate typically provides dependable service, but it usually is not ...

Geico vs. Allstate 9.3 vs. 9.1 $3,340 (67% more expensive) Allstate has higher coverage ratings, but we found Geico is a more affordable provider. Geico vs. USAA 9.3 vs. 9.3 $1,741 (13% cheaper ...